NEA Representative Assembly in New Orleans – 2010

NEA Representative Assembly in New Orleans – 2010

The theme for this year’s NEA Representative Assembly in New Orleans was “Hope Turned into Action”, that is, it seems, for everyone but ex-gays.
This year I spoke at the Resolutions Committee Open Hearing asking that in Resolution B 14a “ex-gays” be added to the list of individuals (gays, lesbians, bisexuals, transgenders) needing protection from discrimination. Following is the rationale I presented to the committee.

1. A June 26, 2009 Washington, D.C. Superior Court ruling in Parents and Friends of Ex-gays (PFOX) vs. D.C. Office of Human Rights, 2008CA003662, identified ex-gays as a protected class under sexual orientation.

2. Contrary to popular belief, no scientific research to date shows that homosexuality is innate, but rather science points to multiple, complex factors. The researchers from the studies which have been quoted as proving that homosexuality is innate say that their research has been misinterpreted.

Researcher, Dr. Simon LeVay, – in the famous 1991 “gay gene” study reported in Science magazine… “It is important to stress what I didn’t find. I did not prove that homosexuality is genetic, or find a genetic cause for being gay. I didn’t show that gay men are born that way, the most common mistake people make in interpreting my work. Nor did I locate a gay center in the brain.”

Studies of identical twins to date show homosexuality is not innate.
In a 1991 Bailey/Pillard study, 52% of male identical twins (raised in same households) were both homosexual. If homosexuality had been genetic, 100% would have both been homosexual. In other studies, the percentages of identical twins being homosexual were significantly lower.

3. The misconception that this category of protection is not needed, since if someone is not homosexual, bisexual or transgender, they fit the category of heterosexual. Ex-gays are discriminated against and often silenced because they are ex-gay, not because they are heterosexual. It is a completely separate class under sexual orientation. Most heterosexuals cannot say they are ex-gay.

4. Because ex-gays are discriminated against and silenced, the message of hope for those with unwanted same-sex attraction is being withheld from those desiring it. Students and school personnel are not given the right to hear all the information to make informed decisions which could have possible psychological, social and health consequences. According to the American Psychological Association in 2008, “mental health organizations call on their members to respect a person’s right to self-determination.”

As a Washington, D.C. court has recently determined, and as the NEA champions social justice, please add ex-gays to the list of individuals needing protection under sexual orientation within the NEA.

The request was denied.

As a side note, once again this year, as chair of the NEA Ex-gay Educator’s Caucus, I wrote a letter to President Dennis VanRoekel requesting ex-gay representation on the NEA SOGI Committee (Sexual Orientation and Gender Identification). Once again, to date that request was denied.

Respectfully submitted,

Susan Halvorson
NEA Ex-gay Educators’ Caucus Chair

Please excuse the lateness of the report. Computer woes along with preparation for the new school year contributed greatly to the delay.

Comments Off on NEA Representative Assembly in New Orleans – 2010

Filed under NEA Convention

Comments are closed.